5 Common Mistakes Every New Gold and Silver Buyer Makes

Back in a time before most of us were even born when America minted coins from gold and silver bullion (pre-1933 and pre-1965, respectively), precious metals ownership or "stacking" was simply a part of everyday life. However, the uses for gold and silver have fundamentally transformed under the current Fiat money system, and today, an increasing number of people understand the need to hold physical precious metals in their portfolio, whether vaulted or at home.

Gold and silver bullion are a proven store of value, offering a hedge against currency devaluation and the resulting inflation that Fiat money systems inevitably create. In addition, bullion's tangibility and absolute lack of counterparty risk provide unique portfolio protection during economic uncertainty and unexpected currency crises.

But stepping into the world of gold and silver buying, or "stacking," can be daunting for newcomers. Without proper knowledge and preparation, new investors are prone to making mistakes that can undermine their investment goals. Understanding these common pitfalls is the first step toward making informed decisions in your precious metals journey. Our goal today is to highlight five frequent mistakes that every new gold and silver buyer makes, offering insights to confidently navigate this complex market.

Let's dive in!

Mistake #1: Not Doing Enough Research

The allure of gold and silver can lead many new investors to rush into significant purchases without conducting adequate research. But first, understanding the market dynamics, the different forms of gold and silver investments (bullion, coins, ETFs, mining stocks, etc.), and the historical performance of these metals is crucial.

Types of Gold and Silver Investments

Each form of investment comes with its own set of considerations. For example, physical bullion has product authenticity and storage concerns, while ETFs and mining stocks are subject to market risk and management company performance. Ignoring the specifics of each option can lead to choices that do not align with one's investment strategy or risk tolerance.

Historical Performance Analysis

Looking at how gold and silver have performed over time in different economic climates can provide valuable insights into their potential future behavior. Neglecting this analysis might result in misplaced expectations about returns on investment (ROI).

Importance of Market Trends

A multitude of factors, including economic indicators, geopolitical stability, and changes in demand and supply, influence the prices of gold and silver. Ignoring these elements can lead to buying at a peak or selling at a low.

In summary, lacking thorough research is a significant misstep for newcomers in the precious metals market. Individuals can make better decisions that align with their financial goals and risk appetite by dedicating time to understanding the intricacies of acquiring gold and silver exposure.

gold bullion coins currency calculator pimbex

Mistake #2: Ignoring the Costs Associated with Buying and Selling

A common oversight for new gold and silver buyers is underestimating the various transaction costs. These costs can significantly impact the overall profitability of an investment in precious metals and understanding and accounting for these expenses is crucial for making informed decisions.

Premiums Above Spot Price

When purchasing gold and silver bullion, investors will notice that prices for the physical product are often above the market's quoted spot price. This price difference or "premium" covers the production and distribution costs of retail bullion products and includes a small profit margin for the dealer. For physical gold and silver, premiums can vary widely depending on the form (bullion coins, bars, rounds) and the item's rarity or collectability.

Sales Taxes and Import Duties

Depending on the jurisdiction, buying gold and silver may be subject to sales taxes, further increasing the acquisition cost. Not everyone is aware of these potential charges at the time of purchase, leading to unexpected expenses that can eat into investment gains.

Transaction Fees

Whether buying or selling gold and silver, transaction fees can apply, especially when using online platforms or broker services. These fees vary by service provider and can include percentages of the transaction value or fixed costs. Certain gold brokers charge brokerage fees and build in outrageous markup over the cost of the metal. PIMBEX uses transparent pricing and does not charge any hidden fees. The price you see at Checkout is the price you pay. Additionally, paying via bank transfer (Bank ACH or Bank Wire) typically allows customers access to the lowest prices on our website, so make sure you are getting the most bang for your buck.

Shipping and Insurance

Shipping and insurance costs are crucial for physical gold and silver purchases. Shipping heavy, valuable packages through carriers is an expensive, risky business. Investors should consider these expenses in their total investment calculation to avoid surprises. Luckily, PIMBEX includes free, fully insured shipping when your order total exceeds $299. It always pays to take advantage of the free shipping!

In summary, overlooking the costs associated with buying and selling gold and silver can lead to a misjudgment of the investment's actual cost and potential profitability. By being mindful of these expenses, new investors can more accurately assess their investment strategies and make choices that align with their financial goals.

Mistake #3: Having Unrealistic Expectations

Entering the gold and silver market with unrealistic expectations about returns can set beginners up for disappointment and potentially riskier decisions. Like any investment, precious metals have their ups and downs, influenced by various global economic factors.

Expecting Immediate Profits

One common misconception is expecting immediate and high returns from gold and silver investments. While these metals can provide excellent long-term value preservation, their short-term price movements can be unpredictable and influenced by factors beyond an investor's control, such as geopolitical tensions, inflation rates, and changes in demand. Investors anticipating quick profits might make hasty decisions, such as buying at peak prices or selling during temporary dips, which can lead to losses.

Misjudging Market Volatility

Gold and silver markets are subject to volatility, just like stocks and other commodities. Prices fluctuate widely based on market sentiment, currency values, and economic indicators. New investors might be unprepared for this volatility, leading to panic selling or excessive buying during market swings. Understanding that price fluctuations are part of the investment process in precious metals is essential for maintaining a steady, long-term approach.

Overestimating the Hedge Against Inflation

While gold and silver are historically considered good hedges against inflation, their performance can vary. Relying solely on precious metals to protect against inflation without considering other factors or diversifying investments can be a misstep. The effectiveness of gold and silver as an inflation hedge depends on the timing of purchases, the holding period, and broader market conditions.

In summary, having unrealistic expectations about gold and silver investments can lead to impulsive decisions and potential financial losses. It's essential to stay within your means and avoid situations where you might be forced to sell. Setting realistic goals, being prepared for market volatility, and understanding the role of precious metals in a diversified investment portfolio is crucial for success in the precious metals market.

pure buy sell hold gold silver bullion pimbex

Mistake #4: Misunderstanding Liquidity and Sellability

One common misunderstanding among new gold and silver investors is overestimating the liquidity of their investments. Liquidity refers to how quickly and easily an asset can be sold at the market price without affecting its value. While gold and silver are generally considered liquid assets, various factors can influence their "sellability."

Liquidity of Different Forms of Precious Metals

Physical gold and silver, such as coins and bullion, are highly liquid in global markets. However, the ease of selling and the price received can vary significantly depending on the item's form, purity, and the current market demand. Specialty bullion or collectible coins and bars, for instance, may take longer to sell or might only trade hands for the value of the metal without any consideration for the initial purchase price.

Impact of Market Conditions

Market conditions can also affect liquidity. During times of high demand, sellers may find it easier to liquidate their holdings at favorable prices. Conversely, in market downturns, finding a buyer might be more challenging, or it may require selling at a discount. Focusing your stack on the most popular gold and silver bullion products, such as the American Eagle Coin or Canadian Maple Leaf series, will help avoid these situations.

Selling Channels and Costs

New stackers might not be aware of the best channels for selling their gold and silver, which can affect the speed and efficiency of the transaction. Selling through dealers, online platforms, or direct sales to other collectors can offer advantages and disadvantages. Additionally, transaction fees, shipping costs, and insurance can all affect the final return on investment. Selling person-to-person (P2P) via online marketplaces like eBay will help you get top dollar. Still, it can take additional time and is a riskier proposition than selling directly back to your dealer.

In summary, misunderstanding the liquidity and sellability of gold and silver can lead to frustration and financial losses for new investors. It is crucial to have realistic expectations about the ease of selling precious metals and to consider these factors when planning an investment strategy.

Mistake #5: Focusing Solely on Short-term Gains

Many new investors enter the gold and silver market with an eye toward quick profits, often driven by short-term price movements or speculative trends. However, this approach can overlook the fundamental value of gold and silver as long-term investments.

The Allure of Short-term Trading

The volatility in gold and silver prices can tempt investors looking to make fast profits through short-term trading. However, this strategy requires a deep understanding of market trends, economic indicators, and geopolitical factors influencing precious metals spot prices. Without this knowledge, investors risk making poorly timed trades that can result in unnecessary losses.

Neglecting Long-term Stability

Gold and silver have historically served as stores of value and protection against economic uncertainty and inflation over the long term. Investors may miss out on the benefits of holding precious metals as part of a diversified portfolio strategy by focusing solely on short-term gains. These benefits include owning assets uncorrelated with the stock market and preserving your purchasing power over time.

Costs of Frequent Trading

Frequent buying and selling of gold and silver can incur additional costs, such as transaction fees, taxes, and spreads between buy and sell prices, eroding profits. It is generally preferable to enter into a long-term hold strategy and only liquidate in incremental amounts when absolutely necessary.

In summary, focusing exclusively on short-term gains in the gold and silver market can distract investors from the long-term value and stability that these metals can provide. Adopting a long-term perspective helps in making more informed decisions, aligning with financial goals, and potentially achieving steady growth and protection against economic fluctuations.

canadian gold maple leaf bullion coins stacked on table pimbex


Embarking on the journey of gold and silver investing is an exciting venture that holds the promise of diversifying portfolios, preserving wealth, and potentially earning returns. However, as we have explored, it is a path fraught with common pitfalls that can trap new gold and silver stackers. From failing to conduct thorough research into the asset class to having unrealistic expectations, ignoring the associated costs, misunderstanding liquidity, and focusing solely on short-term gains, these mistakes can significantly impact the long-term success of your precious metals holdings.

The key to navigating the complex market of gold and silver lies in education and patience. Taking the time to understand the nuances of precious metals, recognizing the importance of a long-term strategy, and staying up to date with market trends and economic indicators can help keep you on the right track. Moreover, embracing the principles of diversification, considering the potential total costs of ownership, and maintaining realistic expectations about returns will equip investors with the knowledge to navigate any market turbulence.

Remember, investing in gold and silver is not about quick wins but building a resilient financial portfolio that can withstand the test of time against the weakening US Dollar. By learning from the common mistakes outlined here today, beginners can approach the market with confidence, ready to capitalize on the inherent value and stability that gold and silver offer.

As you continue your stacking journey, keep these lessons in mind. With careful planning, a clear understanding of the market, and a commitment to long-term objectives, you can avoid these pitfalls and work towards achieving your financial dreams.

And while you are here, we encourage you to shop our trusted selection today!

Image of purchased product.
Begin Checkout

Product Name

Item added to cart

Unit Price: *Extended Price: *Cart Subtotal:

*Extended Price for Bank Wire or ACH payments only. Other forms of payment will modify the cost per unit.

Volume Pricing Discount

  • Quantity
  • ACH/Wire
  • Credit Card

Processing Request...